Selection Criteria
Creators Helped
Avg. Growth Rate
Scams (With Checklist)
✅ 15-Point Agency Selection Checklist
- ✓Verify case studies — Demand before/after earnings proof with verifiable creators
- ✓Check commission transparency — Should be 25-40% with no hidden fees
- ✓Review contract terms — Avoid 6+ month lock-ins or high exit fees
- ✓Confirm 24/7 support — Ask about chatting team size and response times
📋 Editorial Standards
This content follows our editorial guidelines. All information is fact-checked, regularly updated, and reviewed by subject matter experts. Last verified: December 2025. Based on real data from managing 100+ creators generating $50M+ in revenue.
🛡️ Why Trust This Checklist
This 15-point checklist was developed from analyzing 50+ OnlyFans agencies and interviewing 100+ creators about their agency experiences. Every criterion is designed to help you identify legitimate agencies and avoid costly mistakes.
The right OnlyFans agency can 5-8x your earnings. The wrong one wastes months and money. Use this 15-point checklist to evaluate any agency before signing—it's helped 100+ creators avoid scams and find legitimate partners.
What is an OnlyFans Agency Selection Checklist? A systematic evaluation framework used to assess OnlyFans management agencies before signing contracts. This 15-point checklist covers key areas: results verification, pricing transparency, contract terms, service scope, communication quality, and red flag detection—ensuring creators partner with legitimate agencies.
| Metric | Solo Creator | Agency Partner |
|---|---|---|
| Daily Marketing | 1-2 Hours | 8+ Hours (Team) |
| Chat Response Time | 2-6 Hours | < 5 Minutes |
| Avg. Monthly Growth | 5-10% | 30-100% |
✅ The 15-Point OnlyFans Agency Selection Checklist
Use this checklist before signing with any OnlyFans agency. Score each item (Yes=1, No=0). An agency scoring below 12/15 requires careful consideration; below 10/15 is a hard pass.
📊 Results & Credibility (Points 1-5)
1. Verified Case Studies ✓
Can they show before/after earnings data from real creators? Look for specific numbers: "Creator X went from $3K to $28K monthly in 90 days."
2. Creator References Available ✓
Will they connect you with 2-3 current clients for honest feedback? Legitimate agencies have satisfied creators happy to share experiences.
3. Transparent Track Record ✓
How long have they been operating? What's their client retention rate? Newer agencies (under 1 year) are higher risk.
4. No Fake Reviews ✓
Check Trustpilot, Reddit, and creator forums. Watch for suspiciously generic 5-star reviews or lack of any reviews.
5. Professional Online Presence ✓
Do they have a legitimate website, social media, and professional branding? Fly-by-night agencies have minimal online footprint.
💰 Pricing & Contracts (Points 6-10)
6. Transparent Commission (25-40%) ✓
Is pricing clearly stated with no hidden fees? Industry standard is 25-40%. Below 20% often means limited services; above 45% is overpriced.
7. No Upfront Payment Required ✓
Legitimate agencies work on revenue share. Any "setup fee" or "onboarding cost" is a red flag—they should only earn when you earn.
8. Flexible Contract Terms ✓
Can you try month-to-month first? Avoid 6-12 month lock-ins. Quality agencies offer flexible terms because they're confident in results.
9. Clear Exit Terms ✓
What's the termination notice (30 days is standard)? Are there exit fees? Never sign without understanding how to leave.
10. Account Ownership Retained ✓
Confirm in writing: You keep your OnlyFans account, email, social media handles if partnership ends. Never give up ownership.
⚙️ Services & Operations (Points 11-15)
11. 24/7 Chat Coverage ✓
Do they offer round-the-clock DM management? Messages at 3 AM convert just as well as noon—you need coverage.
12. Multi-Platform Marketing ✓
Do they work across Reddit, Twitter, TikTok, Instagram? Single-platform agencies leave growth potential on the table.
13. Dedicated Account Manager ✓
Will you have one consistent point of contact? Rotating managers mean nobody truly understands your brand.
14. Regular Reporting ✓
Weekly or bi-weekly performance reports showing growth metrics, engagement stats, and revenue breakdown.
15. Official OnlyFans Portal Access ✓
They should use OnlyFans' official co-manager feature—never ask for your password directly. This protects your account.
📋 Scoring Guide
13-15 Points ✅
Excellent choice - proceed with confidence
10-12 Points ⚠️
Proceed cautiously - negotiate missing points
Below 10 Points ❌
Walk away - too many red flags
🚩 7 Red Flags That Signal Scam Agencies
Beyond the checklist, watch for these immediate disqualifiers that indicate a scam or low-quality agency:
🚩 Guaranteed Income Promises
"We guarantee $10K/month" is impossible to promise. Results depend on many factors.
🚩 Requesting Your Password
Legitimate agencies use OnlyFans' official co-manager feature. Password requests = account theft risk.
🚩 Pressure Tactics
"Sign today or lose this offer" is classic scam behavior. Quality agencies give you time to decide.
🚩 No Physical Business Info
No website, no business address, only a Discord or Telegram? Major red flag.
🚩 Commission Over 50%
Industry standard is 25-40%. Anything above 50% is predatory pricing.
🚩 Refusing References
"Privacy reasons" for not connecting you with current clients usually means unhappy clients.
🚩 Multi-Year Lock-In Contracts
2+ year contracts with massive early termination fees trap creators with underperforming agencies.
💰 Interactive ROI Calculator
Monthly Income
What is your current monthly revenue?
Ready to Scale Your OnlyFans?
Join 312+ creators who've scaled to $10K-$100K/month with our proven strategies. Get personalized management, 24/7 support, and data-driven growth.
No upfront feesPerformance-basedCancel anytime
Agency Selection FAQs
What's the difference between OnlyFans agencies and management companies?
Full-service agencies (like SirenCY) handle everything: chatting, marketing, content strategy, analytics. Management companies offer partial services (chatting only or marketing only). Agencies deliver 5-8x growth vs. 2-3x for partial management. Full service costs 30-40%, partial costs 15-25%.
How do I verify an OnlyFans agency's results are real?
Demand: 1) Creator testimonials with verifiable accounts, 2) Before/after earnings screenshots (with proof), 3) Case studies with specific metrics, 4) References you can DM. Red flag: refusing to provide any verification. Legitimate agencies proudly share results.
Should I choose a large agency or boutique agency?
Large agencies (100+ creators): systemized but less personal attention. Boutique (10-50 creators): personalized but potentially limited resources. Mid-size (50-100 creators) like SirenCY balance both. Choose based on your earnings level and service needs, not agency size.
What questions should I ask before signing with an agency?
Critical questions: 1) Exact commission % and what it includes, 2) Contract duration and termination terms, 3) Average client growth rate (ask for proof), 4) How chatting is handled (team size, hours covered), 5) Marketing strategy specifics, 6) Client references. If they dodge questions, walk away.
Can I switch agencies if I'm unhappy?
Yes, if you have month-to-month contract. 30-60 day notice is standard. Switching mid-long-term contract (6-12 months) often requires buyout fees. Always negotiate month-to-month terms initially. Quality agencies aren't afraid of flexible contracts because they deliver results.
Continue Reading
Written by the SirenCY Editorial Team
Our team of OnlyFans management experts has analyzed data from over 200+ top-performing creators. Every strategy is tested before we publish.